They're not the brother...says who?   Yeah, fast talk isn't wrong either. It just depends on what you're trying to achieve. I think the disconnect we're having here is that you're assuming a context: the PC arbitrarily selects some faceless fodder enemy in robes and claims to be their sibling for some momentary advantage. In that case I'd agree with you and go a lot further--I wouldn't allow a roll at all. People are in general aware of their immediate family, and you're right that som