List your player deaths as and when they happen. Let us grieve for these brave investigators.
Ralph Brown. Manservant. b.1895 - d.1921
While staking out the roof of a strange tower (the rest of the players inside on the ground floor or outside waiting), Ralph was taken by a Hunting Horror looking for its sacrifice.
He would have survived, writhing in pain (Wrack) on the flat roof had not the players accidentally killed the sacrifice the bad guys had teleported in with. The intended sacrifice was made to stand on the trapdoor to the roof to prevent anyone coming through. A double barreled shotgun later from the player Detective and she was dead, leaving the soon-to-arrive Horror with no choice but to find another victim.
Directed to the prone player, now temporarily insane AND writhing in pain, a big gulp and a bite later and Ralph was no more, leaving just his shoes (with feet) behind.
A small plaque was placed in the village graveyard, above the shoe box that contained the last of his remains.