*inspired by the "worst 3 suppliments" topic*
(Instead of lambasting authors for their "worst" suppliments, why not discuss what's been published that is beyond the realm of kicking ass, and ask for more?)
Sure, everyone has their likes and dislikes as to how they play CoC, or any game. But you do have to admit, just like movies, there IS a distinctive line of quality that can (and sometimes must) be drawn. You just can't lump "Plan 9 From Outer Space" with "Close Encounters of the Third Kind."
So, where do you, as a player/keeper, draw the line of quality? What do you see in suppliments that's exemplary? What's lacking? Anything untried that you'd like to see? Consider this your wishlist.