Joined: Sep 19, 2003 Posts: 866 Location: High Wycombe, SE England
Posted: Fri Dec 19, 2003 11:05 pm Post subject: Re: Leaving the Tcho-Tcho behind
FunGuyfromYuggoth wrote:
Quite honestly, I don't care for using the Tcho-Tcho in my campaigns and would ask the greater gaming community to stop and take stock of what the Tcho-Tcho actually signified to HPL.
They are the embodiment of the ugliest stereotypes that HPL and 1920's America harbored for Asians. If we can live without HPL's racial biases and play a roleplaying game incorporates modern people on a global stage, can we not live without his most racially loaded creation?
Leaving the Tcho-Tcho behind would be no great loss and in fact would signify that we've finally parted with Lovecraft on this matter. The universe of the Mythos is rich with cruel human ambition, terrifying monsters, unknowable god-like aliens, and wicked conspiracies. We shouldn't have to wallow in this one great failing of HPL, when we now know better ourselves.
Please give this some thought.
OK thought about it and rejected it. I dont really care what HPL was trying to embody, I try to have fun on a monday night and the Tcho Tcho are to much fun to just discard, I'll leave the political correctness at the door and just try and think about horror of all types. Anyway I have enough EOWG's in my campaign that I need some ethnic balance.
Giles "political correctness bah humbug" Hill _________________ I've been shot at once, blown up twice, stoned more times than I can remember hell I've even been stapled, none of which ever worried me more than the threat of a swift kick in the balls.
The one thing that was safe, however--that never drew any criticism--was the use of white Anglo/German males as villains. Some stereotypes are, apparently, okay, while others are not.
You've hit the nail right on the head. People aren't willing to look for context. As an example, a friend of mine told me a Jewish rights advocacy group was trying to sue the makers of a wargame which featured the Nazis wearing the SS custom swastika . Now admittedly my knowledge of history isn't the sharpest, but I seem to remember Nazi artwork and medals featured that emblem quite prominently.
Also, some Japanese software and game manufacturers have been sued for using the <i>original</i> swastika which appears in Buddhism, which the Nazis turned on its side to form their own distinctive mark.
To get back on track, are some Tcho-Tchos evil? Yeah, probably so. Are they all bad? No, I don't think so. _________________ Anata sekai o kakumei surush ga nai deshou?
Anata no susumu michi wa yoi shimashita.
Well, first of all, I believe Tcho-tchos are fictional. According to the d20 manual, their very culture is 'evil' and canibalistic, so as long they are raised in it, they will be too. 'Non-corrupted' tcho-tchos are those which haven't had any contact with the tcho-tcho culture.
I believe that Tcho-Tchos were originally from The Horror from the Hills, introducing Chaugnar Faugn, but I could be wrong.
They are not just short Asian people, but literally inhuman Mythos hybrids. Possibly, if you accept the Hyperborean interpretation, they're not even partly Homo sapiens sapiens. An individual Tcho-Tcho might be brought up to act in a reasonably human fashion, but their brains are hardwired with a different potential (not necessarily evil, any more than a shark or a toad is evil).
edit: Let me clarify that: Their culture is evil and corrupt beyond any human cannibal culture or devil-worship. Their genes are not evil, but in human terms they could be called natural sociopaths.
I believe that Tcho-Tchos were originally from The Horror from the Hills, introducing Chaugnar Faugn, but I could be wrong.
I double-checked Chris' bib on this, and there don't seem to be Tcho-Tcho references in there. I think much of the material from Long's novel was later incorporated into Tcho-Tcho lore by later writers, hence the confusion.
The Tcho-Tchos, if they indeed worship Zhar, Lloigor, and Chaugnar Faugn, seem intenesely interested with different realities and energies. Chaugnar Faugn is multidimensional; that's why ol CF is so darned hard to damage. Lloigor and Zhar disintegrate living matter whenever they touch it. These two also seem able to manipulate their shapes to fit through small cracks. Perhaps they too are able to exist in more than one dimension at the same time.
Chaugnar Faugn also built a race of dwarves which serve him, the Miri Nigri. Perhaps He played some part in the creation of the Tcho-Tchos as well. This (and this is pure conjecture here) may have come in the insertion of some supernatural essence, for lack of a better word, into the first Tcho-Tcho person, who had been a normal individual before the evil infusion.
If in fact it is the Tcho-Tchos who are evil and not their culture which is evil, accepting that they are not in fact wholly human helps us to understand if not excuse their cannibalistic tendencies. _________________ Anata sekai o kakumei surush ga nai deshou?
Anata no susumu michi wa yoi shimashita.
Chaugnar Faugn also built a race of dwarves which serve him, the Miri Nigri. Perhaps He played some part in the creation of the Tcho-Tchos as well. This (and this is pure conjecture here) may have come in the insertion of some supernatural essence, for lack of a better word, into the first Tcho-Tcho person, who had been a normal individual before the evil infusion.
The old scenario "The Curse of Chaugnar Faugn" makes the Tcho-Tcho the offspring of the Miri Nigri and normal humans.
Joined: Nov 24, 2003 Posts: 468 Location: Reading, Berkshire
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2003 11:26 am Post subject: Chatanooga Tcho - Tcho no go
Indeed Lovecraft did have many of the prejudices of his time.
However one should bear in mind that the Tcho-tcho are not simply cannabalistic asian humans, but a distinctive culture and race, one that in Delta Green Cannon will be virtually extingished from the face of the planet by the Vietcong and NVA, with a few being rescued by the CIA and a small number reaching the US. A very distinctive case is made that the Tcho-Tcho and the people around them are not of the same race, or maybe origin (unlike say humans and ghouls).
Is it racist, well maybe it was in its origin, but that doesn't mean it has to be now - Just because an evil mythos race is of Oriental origin, and that Lovecraft was racist, doesn't mean that this has to be the case. The Mythos is supposed to exist in far away hidden places, and as such many stories and scenarios are set in obscure and ancients locals. But worshipers and cults are found world wide, with localised flavour. _________________ Not dead by dreaming
Joined: Apr 29, 2003 Posts: 1861 Location: Chengdu, China
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2003 9:35 am Post subject:
This has nothing to do with the Tcho-Tcho, just a warning.
Anyway, i'd like to ammend my original idea of a 20's Caribbean book and say it should go down into Brazil and the rubber barrons, plus some stuff about the panama canal and the Amazon river. Then a Pulp section for the 30's and flying boats. Flying boats rule.
Joined: Sep 20, 2003 Posts: 2942 Location: Approximately 51.07°N, 0.00°W
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2003 12:27 pm Post subject:
CAThompson wrote:
This has nothing to do with the Tcho-Tcho, just a warning.
That's OK, I don't remember starting a thread about Tcho-Tcho
Wouldn't mind seeing a sourcebook on them though. _________________ We do not stop playing because we get old; we get old because we stop playing - George Bernard Shaw
Joined: Jul 19, 2003 Posts: 5027 Location: Los Angeles, CA, USA
Posted: Sat Dec 27, 2003 5:03 am Post subject: Holiday fantasies
I know it's nice to fantasize here about what supplements you want to see, but in reality, until somebody decides to venture and complete the task, it's seems that it's a lot to put upon a game company that clearly has its hands/tentacles full.
Anybody here with a background in game publishing, please chime in.
There was a time in the 1980s and 1990s when Chaosium seemed to churn out a new supplement every few months. I always looked forward to their catalogs by mail. Was it that long ago? Yes...
Is it time writing, time editing? Cost/cashflow issues? Problems with distribution? Given the high quality of material that has come out of Chaosium over the years, its remarkable to me that they were able to balance the quality/demand issue.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can syndicate our news using an RSS/XML feed via backend.php, and our forum posts via backendforums.php
Logos and trademarks are property of their respective owners. Comments are the responsibility of their posters.